Amish Tomato Pie – The Best Comfort Dish to Try This Summer

Table of Contents: Amish Tomato Pie

Amish Tomato Pie

Introduction

When summer rolls around and tomatoes are bursting with flavor, there’s one traditional dish that brings together rustic comfort and farm-fresh ingredients — Amish Tomato Pie. This old-fashioned pie combines juicy ripe tomatoes, tangy mayonnaise, savory herbs, and melted cheese in a golden, flaky crust. Whether you’ve tried Southern tomato pie or never heard of it before, the Amish version brings a wholesome, authentic twist to the table.

In this article, we’ll explore the rich history of Amish cooking, the best ways to avoid soggy crusts, and a step-by-step guide to making your own tomato pie at home. You’ll also discover how it compares to famous versions from Utica and Philadelphia.
Don’t miss our Amish Bread.

The History and Origins of Amish Tomato Pie

What is an Amish Pie? Exploring Its Cultural Roots

Amish pies are more than just a dessert or savory treat — they’re a tradition deeply rooted in simplicity, sustainability, and family gatherings. Known for using fresh, seasonal ingredients grown on Amish farms, these pies reflect the community’s no-waste, wholesome lifestyle. Amish Tomato Pie isn’t a trendy dish — it’s a flavorful legacy passed down through generations.

Traditional Amish Baking: Simple, Wholesome, Flavorful

Amish baking relies on pantry staples: flour, butter, fresh produce, and a lot of heart. The tomato pie is often enjoyed during summer when tomatoes are abundant. Unlike commercial recipes loaded with additives, Amish pies stay true to old-fashioned values — quality over quantity, flavor over flash.

Why Amish Tomato Pie is a Must-Try Dish

The Unique Flavor Profile of Amish Tomato Pie

Amish Tomato Pie strikes a perfect balance between sweet, acidic tomatoes, creamy mayonnaise, and sharp cheddar or mozzarella. The herbs — typically basil, oregano, and thyme — enhance the fresh garden flavors. When baked, the cheese bubbles and browns, and the crust becomes a buttery foundation.

Comparing It to Other Regional Tomato Pies

Compared to Southern Tomato Pie, which sometimes includes bacon or breadcrumbs, the Amish version focuses more on simplicity. Unlike Philadelphia’s tomato pie (which is cheeseless), this pie is cheesy, hearty, and served warm — making it an irresistible comfort meal.
Check out our savory tomato pie if you love savory pies.

Classic Ingredients in an Authentic Amish Tomato Pie

Fresh Produce and Pantry Staples Used

Here’s what you’ll usually find in a classic Amish Tomato Pie:

• Ripe, thick-sliced tomatoes
• Homemade or pre-baked pie crust
• Real mayonnaise (Duke’s is a favorite)
• Shredded cheddar or mozzarella cheese
• Fresh basil and parsley
• Salt, pepper, garlic powder

What Sets Amish Ingredients Apart from Regular Pies

Amish cooking emphasizes purity. Tomatoes are often heirloom or vine-ripened. Cheeses are freshly shredded, and crusts are made from scratch. Even the mayo is often homemade or farm-sourced. This attention to ingredient quality results in a fresher, more flavorful experience.

How to Make Tomato Pie That’s Not Soggy

Kitchen Tips to Prevent a Soggy Crust

Soggy crust is the #1 complaint for tomato pies, but there’s a fix:

• Pre-bake the crust (“blind baking”) for 10-12 minutes
• Brush with egg white to seal it
• Layer a sprinkle of breadcrumbs or grated Parmesan before the filling

Prepping Your Tomatoes: Salt, Drain, Roast

Tomatoes contain a lot of water. Here’s what you should do:

1. Slice them thick
2. Sprinkle with salt
3. Let them sit on paper towels for 30 minutes
4. Optional: roast them at 375°F for 15 minutes to intensify the flavor

Step-by-Step Recipe: Authentic Amish Tomato Pie

Ingredient List and Prep Work

Ingredient	Quantity
Ripe Tomatoes	4–5 large
Pie Crust	1 (9-inch)
Mayonnaise	¾ cup
Shredded Cheddar	1½ cups
Fresh Basil (chopped)	2 tbsp
Garlic Powder	½ tsp
Salt & Pepper	To taste

Easy-to-Follow Baking Instructions

1. Preheat oven to 375°F
2. Blind bake the crust for 10-12 minutes
3. Slice and salt the tomatoes; let them drain
4. Mix cheese, mayo, garlic powder, and herbs
5. Layer tomatoes in crust; top with cheese-mayo mix
6. Bake for 30-35 minutes or until bubbly and golden
7. Let cool before slicing

Best Cheese & Crust Choices for Amish Tomato Pie

Why Cheddar and Mayo are Essential

The cheddar provides a rich, slightly sharp flavor that balances tomato sweetness. Mayo adds creaminess and binds the pie together. Some folks also mix in mozzarella or fontina for a melty texture.

Homemade Crust vs. Store-Bought: Pros and Cons

Type	Pros	Cons
Homemade	Buttery, flakier taste	Takes more time to prep
Store-bought	Quick and convenient	Can be bland or soggy

Utica vs. Philadelphia vs. Amish Tomato Pie: What’s the Difference?

What City is Famous for Tomato Pies?

Both Utica, NY, and Philadelphia, PA are known for tomato pies. Utica’s version is a thick, bread-like crust topped with tomato sauce and served cold. Philly’s version is thinner, crispier, and often eaten room temperature with cheese sprinkled on top.

Comparing Ingredients, Texture, and Serving Style

Version	Key Features
Utica	Thick crust, no cheese, served cold
Philadelphia	Thin crust, tomato-forward, light cheese
Amish	Warm pie, cheesy, rustic, flaky crust

Tips for Serving and Pairing Amish Tomato Pie

Best Side Dishes to Serve with Tomato Pie

Pair this pie with:

• Green bean salad
• Buttermilk cornbread
• Chilled cucumber-dill soup
• Roasted zucchini or squash

When and How to Serve It for Gatherings

Serve warm or at room temperature. Great for potlucks, brunches, and summer BBQs. Slice into squares or wedges and pair with iced tea or homemade lemonade.

Storage, Leftovers, and Reheating Tips

How Long It Stays Fresh in the Fridge

Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days. Don’t freeze — tomatoes get watery when thawed.

Best Ways to Reheat Without Losing Texture

• Reheat in oven at 350°F for 10–15 minutes
• Avoid microwaving; it makes crust soggy
• Use toaster oven for crispy slices

People Also Ask: Amish Tomato Pie

Conclusion: Amish Tomato Pie

Amish Tomato Pie is more than a seasonal favorite — it’s a celebration of simplicity and flavor. Whether you’re from the South, the East Coast, or Midwest, this pie brings families together with each warm, cheesy slice.

Find Us On Pinterest and Facebook.

Print