Easy Homemade NY-Style Pizza Sauce: Authentic Recipe | Quick & Delicious!

Table of Contents: Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

Craving the tangy, herb-kissed sauce that defines a perfect New York slice? This recipe unlocks the secrets to sauce nostalgia—no fancy skills required! Perfect for family pizza nights or impressing your grandkids.

Introduction: Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

There’s magic in a New York-style pizza sauce – that bright, garlicky, just-sweet-enough tomato base supporting molten cheese and crisp crust. Unlike thick, heavily seasoned sauces, authentic NY-style pizza sauce celebrates simplicity.

It’s a fresh-tasting canvas where tomatoes shine, kissed by oregano, basil, and a whisper of garlic. Perfect for Friday night dinners, game-day gatherings, or reviving cherished food memories.

Our recipe skips the simmer-all-day approach. Instead, we gently coax flavor from whole tomatoes, infused onions, and fresh basil. The result? A sauce that’s vibrant, balanced, and freezer-friendly. Whether you’re making classic New York-style pizza or upgrading frozen pies, this homemade sauce will make everyone ask, “What’s your secret?”

Using pantry staples like canned tomatoes and dried oregano, this recipe democratizes gourmet flavor. Imagine your kitchen smelling like your favorite corner pizzeria – that’s the power of authentic NY-style pizza sauce.

Alternate Names & Variations

This sauce goes by many delicious aliases:

• Brooklyn-Style Pizza Sauce
• Classic Pizza Sauce (no-cook version)
• East Coast Pizza Sauce

For a smoother texture, blend the sauce before adding basil. Prefer spicy? Double the red pepper flakes!

Ingredients: Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

• 1 (28-ounce) can whole peeled tomatoes (preferably San Marzano)
• 1 tablespoon (15 ml) extra-virgin olive oil
• 1 tablespoon (15 ml) unsalted butter (adds richness)
• 2 medium cloves fresh garlic, grated on microplane (about 2 teaspoons)
• 1 teaspoon dried oregano
• Pinch red pepper flakes
• Kosher salt (to taste)
• 1 medium yellow onion, peeled and halved
• 2 (6-inch) sprigs fresh basil with leaves attached
• 1 teaspoon sugar (balances acidity)

Step-by-Step Instructions

• Prep Aromatics: Heat olive oil and butter in a saucepan over medium-low. Add grated garlic, oregano, and red pepper flakes. Cook 1 minute until fragrant but not browned.
• Infuse Flavors: Add onion halves (cut-side down) and basil sprigs. Pour in tomatoes with their juices. Use a spoon to crush tomatoes roughly.
• Simmer Gently: Bring to a simmer, then reduce heat to low. Cook uncovered 30 minutes, stirring occasionally.
• Adjust Seasonings: Remove onion and basil. Stir in sugar and salt to taste. For NY-style texture, leave slightly chunky or blend briefly.
• Cool & Use: Let sauce cool before spreading on pizza dough. Avoid overheating fresh basil in baked pizza.

Chef’s Tip: Butter is a NY pizzeria secret! It adds depth without heaviness.

Recipe Card Block (Quick Reference)

Prep Time: 10 minutes | Cook Time: 35 minutes | Total Time: 45 minutes | Servings: 4 (makes ~2½ cups) | Calories: ~180 per cup

Why This Recipe Works & Expert Tips

True New York-style pizza sauce embraces minimalism. The gentle simmer extracts sweetness from onions and basil stems without overcooking tomatoes. Using whole canned tomatoes (not pre-crushed) preserves freshness. Sugar isn’t mandatory but balances acidic tomatoes – taste before adding. For best results:

• Tomato Choice Matters: San Marzano DOP tomatoes offer superior sweetness.
• Skip the Paste: Authentic NY sauce isn’t reduced into paste thickness.
• Fresh vs. Dried Basil: We use fresh for infusion, dried would overpower.

This sauce doubles as a dip for mozzarella sticks or a base for easy comfort food like baked ziti!

Storage, Freezing, and Reheating Tips

Store cooled sauce in an airtight container for up to 1 week refrigerated or 3 months frozen. Freeze portions in ice cube trays for single-pizza use. Thaw overnight in fridge or gently reheat on stovetop. Avoid microwaving – it can scorch garlic.

People Also Ask: Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

How do you make homemade New York-style pizza sauce?

Authentic NY-style pizza sauce starts with quality whole peeled tomatoes gently simmered with garlic, oregano, onion, and fresh basil. Unlike thick sauces, it’s lightly cooked to preserve tomato brightness.

Our recipe uses butter for richness and a touch of sugar to balance acidity, resulting in a sauce that’s thin enough to spread smoothly yet packed with layered flavors. The key is restraint—no heavy herbs or over-reduction. Perfect for topping crispy, foldable New York-style pizza crusts.

What makes a pizza sauce “New York-style”?

New York-style pizza sauce stands out for its simplicity and texture. It’s uncooked (or minimally cooked) before baking to retain fresh tomato flavor. The sauce has a slightly chunky consistency from hand-crushed tomatoes and relies on garlic, oregano, and basil for subtle aroma—never overwhelming the palate.

Authentic versions avoid tomato paste, creating a lighter base that complements generous cheese layers. This style originated in early 20th-century NYC pizzerias where Italian immigrants prioritized quality ingredients over complexity.

Can I use fresh or canned tomatoes?

While fresh summer tomatoes can work, canned whole peeled tomatoes are ideal for consistent NY-style sauce year-round. They’re picked at peak ripeness and canned immediately, ensuring robust flavor. If using fresh, peel and seed plum tomatoes, then simmer longer to concentrate flavor. Avoid watery varieties like beefsteak.

For best results, opt for high-quality canned San Marzano tomatoes (look for “DOP” certification). Their natural sweetness reduces the need for added sugar, staying true to the New York pizza tradition.

How long does this sauce keep in the fridge?

Properly stored in an airtight container, homemade NY-style pizza sauce lasts 5-7 days refrigerated. Ensure it cools completely before sealing. For longer storage, freeze in portioned containers for up to 3 months.

Due to fresh garlic and onions, avoid room temperature storage. To reuse, stir thawed sauce well before applying to pizza. If the sauce separates, a quick blend restores consistency. Always check for off-smells before using refrigerated sauce—its vibrant red color should remain bright.

Conclusion: Homemade Ny-Style Pizza Sauce

Ready to elevate pizza night? This NY-style sauce transforms your kitchen into a corner pizzeria—without the subway ride. Share your bubbling masterpieces with us using #NYStyleSauceMagic or drop a comment below! What’s your favorite pizza topping combo with this sauce? Let’s swap stories (and recipes!) like true New Yorkers.

You Might Also Like:

 – Hibachi Chicken Recipe
– Juicy Slow Cooker Chicken Drumsticks Recipe 🍗 Easy, Flavor-Packed Recipe for Dinner!
– Best Slow Cooker Honey Garlic Meatballs: Easy, Sweet & Savory Family Favorite! 🍯🥢
– Best Cheesy Keto Ground Beef Casserole Recipe – Low-Carb Comfort Food!

Find Us On Pinterest and Facebook.

Print