Tomato Pie – The Best Southern Recipe You’ll Love in Every Bite

Table of Contents

Tomato pie is the kind of dish that screams summer comfort food—rich, savory, and bursting with the sweetness of ripe tomatoes layered in a flaky, golden crust. This Southern favorite has earned its spot at potlucks, backyard dinners, and Sunday brunches across the country. But what makes the perfect tomato pie? From choosing the right tomatoes to mastering a non-soggy crust, we’ve created the most detailed guide you’ll find online.

In this article, you’ll learn everything there is to know about making, serving, storing, and even reinventing tomato pie. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or a curious beginner, we’ve got you covered with step-by-step instructions, tasty variations, and pro tips that guarantee flavor in every bite.

Check out this fresh twist in summer flavors with our Grilled Peaches recipe—perfect for dessert after your tomato pie!

Let’s dive in.

Introduction

What Is Tomato Pie?

It’s a savory baked dish that usually consists of fresh, sliced tomatoes layered over a crust with herbs, cheese, and mayonnaise. Unlike pizza or traditional Italian tomato tarts, Southern-style tomato pie focuses on garden-fresh tomatoes and rich, creamy fillings. It’s both hearty and refreshing—making it a staple during tomato season.

The most common form of this recipe includes a pre-baked pie crust, layers of sliced and salted tomatoes, a cheese-mayo mixture, and a blend of herbs like basil or oregano. It’s then baked until golden and bubbly.

This pie can be served warm, at room temperature, or even cold depending on your preference. It can be a star on its own or a flavorful side dish for grilled meats or summer salads.

The History and Southern Roots

While tomato pies appear in different cultures, the version most Americans recognize has its roots in the Southern United States. Farmers’ markets in states like Georgia, Alabama, and North Carolina popularized this dish as a way to use up an abundance of summer tomatoes.

The Southern tomato pie first appeared in community cookbooks in the early 20th century, often passed down through generations. It symbolizes Southern hospitality—simple ingredients elevated through thoughtful preparation.

What separates this pie from other savory pies is its heavy reliance on fresh, local produce and its nostalgic charm. This dish isn’t just food; it’s a memory served on a plate.

Ingredients You’ll Need for this recipe

Classic Southern Tomato Pie Ingredients

To make this recipe, you’ll want to gather the following ingredients:

Ingredient	Amount	Purpose
Fresh ripe tomatoes	4–5 medium	The star of the dish
Mayonnaise	1/2 cup	Adds creaminess and tang
Shredded cheddar cheese	1 cup	Melty and rich cheese base
Mozzarella cheese	1/2 cup	For stretchy texture
Fresh basil	Handful	Bright, herbaceous flavor
Garlic powder	1 tsp	Boosts flavor subtly
Salt and pepper	To taste	Enhances and balances flavors
Pie crust (store-bought or homemade)	1 crust	The vessel that holds it all

Don’t miss our creamy Peach Ice Cream recipe that pairs deliciously with savory dishes like this!

Fresh vs. Canned Tomatoes: Which Works Best?

Always go fresh. The essence of a good pie lies in the juicy sweetness of vine-ripened tomatoes. Using canned tomatoes introduces excess liquid and often lacks the depth of flavor found in fresh varieties like:

• Heirloom tomatoes
• Roma tomatoes
• Beefsteak tomatoes

However, if you’re out of fresh tomatoes, canned can work in a pinch—just make sure to drain them thoroughly and use paper towels to soak up extra moisture. But to keep that authentic flavor and texture, fresh is always best.

Step-by-Step Guide

Preparing the Crust: Homemade or Store-Bought?

The foundation of a good tomato pie is a solid crust. You can use a high-quality store-bought crust if you’re in a rush, but making it from scratch takes it to another level. A homemade crust allows you to control the flavor, texture, and thickness. Here’s how to prepare a flaky pie crust at home:

Basic Pie Crust Ingredients:

• 1 ¼ cups all-purpose flour
• ½ teaspoon salt
• ½ cup unsalted butter (cold, cubed)
• 3–4 tablespoons ice water

Steps:

1. Mix flour and salt.
2. Cut in cold butter until it resembles crumbs.
3. Slowly add water until the dough forms.
4. Wrap and chill for 30 minutes before rolling out.
5. Blind bake at 375°F for 10–12 minutes with pie weights.

Blind baking helps the crust hold up to the moisture from the tomatoes.

Layering the Ingredients Perfectly

Once your crust is baked and cooled slightly, it’s time to assemble:

1. Slice and salt the tomatoes. Lay slices on paper towels and sprinkle with salt. Let them sit for 20–30 minutes to draw out excess moisture.
2. Layer basil leaves directly on the crust. This acts as a barrier and infuses flavor.
3. Add a layer of sliced tomatoes.
4. Sprinkle with garlic powder, black pepper, and more herbs.
5. Top with a mix of cheddar, mozzarella, and mayo blended together.
6. Repeat the tomato and cheese-mayo layers as needed.
7. Bake at 375°F for 30–35 minutes until golden and bubbling.

Let the pie cool for at least 15 minutes before slicing.

How to Keep Tomato Pie Crust from Getting Soggy

Why Sogginess Happens and How to Prevent It

Tomatoes are more than 90% water. When baked, they release moisture that can seep into your crust, making it soggy. Here’s why sogginess happens:

• Not salting or draining the tomatoes
• Not blind baking the crust
• Using overripe or overly juicy tomatoes

Best Techniques: Pre-baking, Salting Tomatoes, and More

To avoid a soggy bottom, use these tested methods:

• Salt and drain tomatoes for at least 30 minutes.
• Use paper towels to blot extra moisture.
• Brush the crust with egg white before filling.
• Add a barrier layer like breadcrumbs, Parmesan, or basil leaves.
• Bake on the lower rack of your oven for a crispier bottom.

Want more crispy-edge ideas? Discover great ideas like this Peach Fritter Recipe that uses similar baking methods!

Variations You Should Try

Cheesy Tomato Pie (Mozzarella, Cheddar, or Ricotta?)

Cheese is a key element of Southern tomato pie. You can mix and match based on your taste:

Cheese Type	Flavor Profile	Best Used With
Cheddar	Sharp, bold	Classic tomato pie
Mozzarella	Mild, melty	Great for stretch
Ricotta	Creamy, smooth	Adds richness

Try a blend of cheddar and mozzarella for a balanced, melty center. Or go fancy with goat cheese or gruyère for more depth.

Vegan, Low-Carb, and Gluten-Free Ideas

This pie doesn’t have to be traditional. Here are some ways to customize it:

• Vegan: Use dairy-free cheese, vegan mayo, and an olive oil crust.
• Low-carb: Skip the crust and bake in a ramekin or use almond flour crust.
• Gluten-free: Use gluten-free pie crusts or a base made from mashed potatoes or polenta.

These versions keep the essence of the dish while catering to different dietary needs.

How to Store and Reheat Tomato Pie Properly

Should Tomato Pie Be Refrigerated?

Yes. Because of the cheese and mayo, this pie should be refrigerated. Once cooled to room temperature, cover with plastic wrap or foil and store in the refrigerator for up to 4 days.

Reheating Tips: Oven vs. Microwave

Reheating tomato pie the right way keeps it from turning rubbery or mushy.

• Oven (Best Method): Preheat to 350°F. Bake for 10–15 minutes. This preserves the crust’s crispness.
• Microwave (Fast but Floppy): Microwave for 1–2 minutes, but expect a softer texture.

Serving it – Hot, Warm, or Cold?

Can You Eat Tomato Pie Cold?

Absolutely. Tomato pie is delicious hot out of the oven, but it’s equally good at room temp—or even cold. Chilled tomato pie has a firmer texture and deeper flavor, especially the day after baking.

It makes a great lunchbox or picnic item when served cold.

Best Side Dishes to Pair with Tomato Pie

Balance the richness of the pie with lighter sides:

• Arugula salad with lemon vinaigrette
• Roasted green beans or zucchini
• Cold cucumber-dill yogurt dip
• Corn on the cob

Looking for inspiration? Try our Grilled Peaches as a fresh and sweet side option.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Tomato Pie

Using Overly Juicy Tomatoes

Choosing the wrong tomatoes is the most common error. Avoid:

• Overripe heirlooms that gush liquid
• Unseasoned or underripe tomatoes
• Tomatoes that haven’t been salted and drained

Stick to firm, fleshy varieties and let them rest on paper towels to reduce water.

Not Letting the Pie Cool Properly Before Cutting

It’s tempting to cut into the pie right away, but waiting 15–20 minutes helps it set and prevents messy slices.

Cool it on a wire rack so the crust stays crisp and doesn’t steam from underneath.

People Also Ask

Conclusion: Why Tomato Pie Deserves a Spot on Your Table

Tomato pie is a nostalgic, flavorful, and flexible dish that truly shines during tomato season. It’s easy to make, easy to love, and adaptable for every diet. Whether you go for the classic cheesy bake or experiment with vegan or low-carb versions, this dish always delivers comfort with a bite of freshness.

Now that you’re ready to master this Southern gem, we hope you try a variation and share your own twist!

Find Us On Pinterest and Facebook.

Print